D r  M . Muneer
D r M . Muneer

To perform better…

… even an investment pro on board investment committee should act as an institutional investment fiduciary
Published on: 
Ralph Ward
Ralph Ward

Effective investment strategies are crucial for an organisation’s long-term success. The board plays a vital role in overseeing these strategies and the investment committee acts as a critical arm in this process.

A well-functioning investment committee serves as a bridge between the board and the investment management team. Its core responsibilities include developing and monitoring investment policy, overseeing investment managers and risk management.

The committee establishes the organisation’s investment policy statement, outlining risk tolerance, asset allocation, and investment objectives. This policy acts as a roadmap for investment decisions. The committee also selects, monitors, and evaluates the performance of investment managers. This includes regular reviews of the portfolio’s alignment with the investment policy statement (IPS) and its risk-return profile. Identifying, assessing and mitigating investment risks is also a key function in ensuring the portfolio remains within acceptable risk parameters.

The boards of trusts, charities, foundations and similar non-profits face a few challenges that corporate boards don’t. Corporates are constantly looking at revenues and cash flow for their spending decisions, while non-profits must focus more on husbanding endowments and fund raising campaigns. In short, the non-profit board is focussed much more on careful management of what’s in the bank than in boosting earnings. This makes investment management crucial, which leads to the importance of a ‘board investment committee’ to specialise on this fiduciary oversight.

Here are some best practices for getting a high-performance investment committee: The setting up of the committee requires the right number and expertise. Aim for a team of 5-6 members – large enough for diverse viewpoints yet small enough for efficient decision-making. Members should possess a blend of investment knowledge, financial expertise, and industry understanding.

Two essentials here are your investment committee charter and investment policy statement. The charter spells out the purpose of the committee, powers and duties, membership, meetings, and authority (and funding) to seek outside advice. Committee membership need not be limited to fiduciary board members but can include staff, consultants and other outsiders (but not for voting purposes). Also, discuss the division of duties between the board as a whole, the committee, a chief investment officer, and outside managers. Here are some good guides and examples.

The IPS is a separate document that spells out the strategy, goals and measures used in investment policy. What are the major goals of investment? How are risk/return measured and balanced? How are investment managers selected and evaluated? What benchmarks are set out for measuring performance? Are there any social/ ethical principles to be weighed in investments?

Next, focus on data-driven decision making. Utilise data analytics to analyse portfolio performance, identify risk factors and assess potential investment opportunities. Employ data visualisation tools to present complex information in clear and concise formats for better committee comprehension.

The third best practice is effective communication and reporting. Ensure transparent communication between the committee, board and investment managers. Regular reporting on portfolio performance, risk metrics and investment rationale ensures trust and facilitates informed decision-making. Benchmark the portfolio’s performance against relevant indices and peer groups to gain insights into relative risk and return. As an example, the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan (OTPP) utilises a comprehensive reporting framework that provides the investment committee with detailed data on portfolio performance, investment risks, and asset class breakdowns. This allows for a data-driven evaluation of investment strategies.

Lastly, investment committees need continuous learning and improvement. Invest in ongoing training for committee members to stay updated on evolving investment strategies, regulatory changes, and advancements in data analytics tools. Conduct periodic reviews of the structure, composition, and effectiveness. Adapt and improve practices based on lessons learned and industry best practices. The Yale University endowment investment committee undergoes periodic self-assessments to evaluate its effectiveness and identify areas for improvement.

One final tip. Who belongs to your investment committee? Experience in the investment sector, finance or banking is valuable, though smaller nonprofits and institutions may have trouble attracting these pros to their boards. If members do have outside roles in these fields, also assure strict disclosure of potential conflicts. Given the complexity of diverse funds and investment options, some conflicts can be so buried the director may not even be aware. Another caveat – clarify that even an investment pro on your committee needs to remember that they are acting as an institutional investment fiduciary, not a retail investor.

M. Muneer is MD, CustomerLab and co-founder, Medici Institute, a non-profit organisation. Ralph Ward is a global authority on boards; both of them drive board alignment for corporations. Contact: Muneer@mediciinstitute.org