An unfair deal? The IDBI Bank’s sale to Fairfax kicks up a controversy 
Government & Politics

Hot debate

Did IDBI’s sale come at a discount?

Rakesh Joshi

Though much desired and belated, the Modi government’s decision to sell a 60.72 per cent stake in IDBI Bank to Canadian financial services group Fairfax Financial Holdings for R52,878 crore has kicked up a controversy and come under scrutiny. Questions are being raised over the valuation, bidding process and rules followed to complete the transaction. The controversy intensified after a media report cited minutes from internal government meetings that purportedly showed changes in the valuation methodology while dealing with bids below the reserve price.

The issue has acquired political overtones with Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition, questioning the need to privatise a bank that has returned to profitability and raising concerns over employee protection and reservation policies. The finance ministry has defended the transaction, saying the bidding process was conducted within the powers delegated to the Core Group of Secretaries on Disinvestment (CGD) and that the valuation was carried out independently, with Fairfax’s final offer emerging higher than the revised valuation benchmark. Nirmala Sitharaman, Finance Minister, personally responded to Rahul Gandhi’s allegations, calling them “lies” and saying that all due process had been followed in the IDBI stake sale.

The crux of the controversy centres on how the government arrived at the final sale price of R81 per share. The government had initially fixed a reserve price of R94.42 per share. However, the first round of bids, opened on 12 March, 2026, failed to meet this price, with both bidders submitting lower offers and refusing to match the reserve price.

According to the finance ministry, Fairfax’s offer of Rs81 per share was higher than the revised independent valuation benchmark of Rs75.99 per share. The transaction is subject to regulatory approvals, including the RBI’s fit-and-proper assessment of the buyer.

Employee protests

But the sale is also facing opposition from the employees of the bank. The United Forum of IDBI Officers and Employees (UFIOE) continued its nationwide strike against the sale ​for a second day, urging the government to halt it. Union representatives have argued that the authorities have taken inconsistent positions on IDBI Bank’s status during the sale process. “When it ​comes to regulation and court rulings, IDBI Bank is treated as a private sector bank. But for valuation ​purposes, it is being compared with public sector banks,” said Devidas Tuljapurkar, convenor of UFIOE, questioning the methodology used to determine the lender’s value.

The transaction involves the sale of 30.48 per cent held by the Government of India and 30.24 per cent held by the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC). After the sale, the government will retain a 15 per cent stake, while LIC will hold 19 per cent. The approved buyer is a subsidiary of Fairfax Financial Holdings, led by Canadian billionaire Prem Watsa.

Watsa’s rise has been legendary. At 22, he was a chemical engineer with a degree from IIT-Madras and had just about $8 in his wallet when he left India for Canada. Fifty-four years later, he is the founder, chairman and chief executive of the Toronto-based $55.5 billion insurance giant Fairfax Financial Holdings.

For Watsa, the IDBI Bank deal is more than acquiring a bank. According to him, it is a bet on his home country’s economic future and a chance to expand a financial empire that has been built over four decades. By clinching this deal, he has created two milestones – flowing the largest FDI into the domestic financial sector and making his largest investment here. Fairfax is spending R52,878 crore to get a controlling stake in IDBI Bank. 

The sale completes a journey that essentially began more than seven-and-a-half years ago in January 2019, when LIC stepped in and provided much-needed funds to the struggling lender while acquiring a majority stake.

Importantly, the IDBI Bank deal announcement also comes almost exactly five years after Tata Sons was confirmed as the buyer of Air India, the last big disinvestment the government undertook. There have been other sales in the interim – Neelachal Ispat Nigam Limited, Ferro Scrap Nigam Limited, and Indian Medicines Pharmaceuticals Corporation Limited – but they are dwarfed by the sheer scale of the money involved. But will the lifting of the IDBI-sized weight give the Ministry of Finance’s disinvestment efforts a second wind?

As the transaction with Fairfax is expected to be completed – which requires final regulatory approvals – by March 2027, the Modi government has essentially met its full-year disinvestment target of R80,000 crore with the entirety of the second half of the fiscal still left.

Observers say that Fairfax’s acquisition must not be judged on valuation alone but on whether it delivers fresh capital, governance and lasting public value.