From the Publisher

Governance begins at home

Venu Srinivasan’s public crusade for corporate governance sits uneasily with the inheritance and control battle unfolding within his own family

Ashok Advani

It is ironic that a battle has broken out in that part of the business of the TVS group controlled by Venu Srinivasan and his immediate family, over issues of governance, control and ownership. These are the very issues that Venu Srinivasan, aided and abetted by Vijay Singh, has been raising vociferously through the media and other channels for the last several months. 

But at home, the boot is on the other foot, with his wife and daughter raising the issues, alleging that Lakshmi Venu, the daughter, is being unfairly short-changed in her fair division of family assets and accusing Venu of non-professionalism when he stepped back in as Chairman and removed a senior officer in Sundaram-Clayton who had been appointed by Lakshmi, and instead appointed a loyalist of his own.

Lakshmi and her mother argue that the law recognises daughters as coparceners in Hindu Undivided Families, with an equal share in joint family properties. And now with the right to demand a partition of family assets.

It is always sad when families aren’t able to sort out differences peacefully within the family, rather than having to get into public arguments and litigation, which ultimately destroy familial relations and also damage the business. 

It is for similar reasons that Venu’s conduct as a trustee and director of Tata Sons Ltd is reprehensible. He (and trustee Vijay Singh) and the other directors of Tata Sons all claim piously to be upholding the values of Ratan Tata, who had brought them into the top tier of decision-making in the Tata Group, after the Cyrus Mistry episode. By joining as trustees and directors, they all readily approved of Ratan’s actions, as the chairman of the Tata Trusts, in removing Cyrus Mistry. Nor was any objection raised to his making Tata Sons a private company, with articles to protect the interests of the Trusts in Tata Sons. And not once in his lifetime did they even raise a single issue of ownership and governance as they are doing now. Ratan Tata must be turning in his grave at the behaviour of all these self-appointed guardians of his values and legacies.

But coming back to the TVS group, Venu has played a stellar role in building TVS Motor into one of the top motorcycle manufacturers in the world. And his wife, Mallika, has also built on her legacy from her paternal family, making TAFE (Tractors and Farm Equipment) into the second-largest (behind Mahindra) tractor manufacturer in India. In many ways, they were the ‘perfect couple’ with two smart and hardworking children. 

We can only hope that the family dispute can be sorted out amicably within the family at the soonest to put an end to the public spectacle.