RBI is clearly overstepping its boundaries in attempting to compel Tata Sons to get listed on the bourses. Nowhere in the world can any regulator compel a company to seek a listing. This is clearly the purview of the capital markets regulator, SEBI in this case, and the stock exchanges.
There is no gainsaying the fact that listing will bring in more liquidity. There are ample examples of well-managed global companies that have chosen to remain unlisted without the constant nagging of regulators to list. These include Cargill, Robert Bosch, Mars and IKEA Holdings, which prefer to remain unlisted to retain control for a long period of time and also allow quick decision-making. Many AI technology companies remain unlisted.
RBI can well say that it derives its powers from being a regulator of NBFCs and that Tata Sons is a designated NBFC in the upper layer. It is really strange how a regulator is selectively using its powers, even in the case of NBFCs. Why was this power not used with IL&FS? Had it pursued the listing of the holding company with the same zeal with which it is hounding Tatas, the entire IL&FS fiasco might not have happened.
RBI’s lethargy in taking decisions to change is too well known to be repeated here. Back in the 1990s, the SLR ledgers took months to transfer securities to the transferee bank, resulting in banks issuing bank receipts, which led to the Securities Scam of 1991. Its throttling regulations saw banks trying to make some more money by giving loans through PMS schemes, which put the entire system at risk, with a few banks issuing more BR than they had securities!
RBI also has to be made accountable for its actions and inaction. Tata Sons had applied to RBI to surrender its Core Investment Company/NBFC certificate sometime in March 2024. This was after it had repaid all its outstanding loans of over R 21,000 crore. RBI took more than 2 years – 29 months, to be precise – to decide whether to accept or reject the application. This smacks of selectivity, if not outright discrimination, against one of the most respected business houses, not just in India but globally.
Shanghavi Finance, the investment arm of Sun Pharma, repaid all its outstanding dues and thereafter applied for deregistration in September 2022. Within a period of six months, RBI accepted the application and deregistered the company.
Tata Sons has also repaid all its outstanding dues. Why is it being given stepmotherly treatment? After Tatas had applied for deregistration, RBI came out with a rule on 29 April 2026 that brought in one more twist by introducing ‘indirect receipt of public funds’ into the definition. Essentially, it broadened the definition by stating that money received not directly, but through group entities that themselves have access to public funds, would also be covered. It expressly refuses to exclude equity from a group company’s own funds, holding that leverage, layering and the fungibility of money make the source impossible to establish.
No industrial companies, let alone Tata, are any threat to the monetary system. In any case, promoters of several large corporate houses hold control through unlisted companies, some of which may well be NBFCs. If RBI pursues the listing of all such companies with missionary zeal, it will only push many of them to seek registration in places like Dubai and Mauritius.
RBI has remained autonomous for decades, and it is best that it remains so and does not bow down to pressure from within the government or outside. Strangely, the top ministers in the government have chosen to maintain a stoic silence despite all the problems. So have the industry bodies and industrialists. The finance minister had gone on record to state that the inter se matters concerning Tata Sons should be resolved amicably. There is no ambiguity on this aspect. When an employee loses the trust and confidence of the employer, he has to resign at the end of his term and leave in a respectful manner.
All the parties wanting a back-door entry into the house of Tatas need to keep in mind that Tatas is not for sale. The respect earned over decades cannot be acquired by anyone simply by buying a stake in the holding company.
It will be a sad day in the annals of corporate history if everyone in power, including a few trustees, connives to allow a back-door entry into an institution whose second name is trust. What sort of signals will global companies wishing to do business in India receive if Tatas are hounded day in and day out to seek a listing and cede control to a third party? Not just global companies but also domestic companies too.
Lastly, RBI needs to understand that its actions are also subject to legal challenges, and quixotic retrospective rule changes will not stand in any court of law.