Editorial

Power grab

Controversy over a co-operative’s poll outcome

Business India Editorial

In a brazen example of overturning the popular mandate and capturing power, the BJP, along with its allies, has captured power in the influential Gokul milk producers’ co-operative. Elections to co-operatives and their outcomes are local issues that hardly create political ripples. But this election has made national headlines, because Gokul is no ordinary co-operative. Launched in 1963, it has a turnover of over R4,200 crore and covers almost 550,000 dairy farmers across Kolhapur district and nearby areas in western Maharashtra, with a catchment of over 1,800 villages. The co-operative supplies milk to a large population in Mumbai and Pune.

More importantly, Gokul commands an impressive political clout in the region. This is what seems to have influenced the ruling alliance in Maharashtra to subvert the mandate. And, so, on 10 November, Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) leader and former MLA Rajesh Patil was elected as chairman of the body after the four directors nominated by the Devendra Fadnavis-led Mahayuti cabinet voted in his favour. This was done through an ordinance to amend the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act 1960, which provides for five government nominees to be appointed on the boards of co-operative federations with an annual turnover above R500 crore that receive government assistance, such as share capital, loans, guarantees, funds or land. Four of these non-official members have voting rights. In the case of Gokul, the four members voted for the Mahayuti, tipping the scales in its favour. The move has now created an undercurrent of uneasiness within the ruling Mahayuti itself, with some leaders worried that it could affect the ruling alliance’s image.

While the move has opened the backdoor to the state government controlling these bodies, which have massive clout over the rural and agrarian economy and wield the levers of power at the grassroots, there are whispers afloat about a grand design to hand over control of Gokul to the Gujarat-based Amul. Critics say that the development raises the larger question of whether a government can change the rules after an election, simply because it does not like the result. Massive protests have broken out in Kolhapur and neighbouring areas. The decision is now being challenged in the Supreme Court as a Bombay High Court bench had refused to intervene in the matter.

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has jumped into the fray, posting on X that, in Gokul, the milk producers defeated the BJP and so the BJP changed the rules after the election – bring in four directors, turn 12 into 16, and ‘steal the majority’. His criticism was in tune with the charge of ‘vote chori’ that he has levelled against the Modi government. “This is theft of the milk producers’ votes – adulteration in the mandate”, Gandhi said. “The BJP has become so desperate that it’s going to any lengths everywhere to save power. Those who steal the milk producers’ votes, remember – farmers don’t forget”.

 Whatever be the criticism, the move upended the mandate and power structure in Gokul. In the run-up to the election, Congress leader and former minister Satej Patil and farmer leader and former MP Raju Shetti had taken on the Mahayuti. Despite being ranged against heavyweight ministers, the Patil and Shetti-led ‘Samavichari Aaghadi’ panel won 13 of the 25 seats. However, despite securing a majority, Patil could not ensure that his nominee, Shashikant Patil Chuyekar, was elected as Gokul chairman. The reason: the quorum required for conducting a meeting is 14, and the absence of the 12 elected representatives of the Mahayuti means a meeting cannot be convened to elect the chairman.

The Fadnavis government maintains that the decision to nominate directors is aimed at increasing transparency, accountability and professionalism. But, intriguingly, it came just days before the meeting of the board was to be held on 10 November, as mandated by the Bombay High Court. 

Since post-independence, Maharashtra’s control over sugar co-operatives and district banks has functioned as a primary conduit for political mobilisation, funding and cadre building – traditionally dominated by Maratha strongmen and the Congress party. Co-operative institutions control local economic lifelines, credit disbursement and employment in Western Maharashtra, making them decisive king-makers in zilla parishads, assembly and parliamentary elections. The late Vasantdada Patil of the Congress party was regarded as a past master in this game.  Now, it is the ruling BJP Mahayuti’s turn to grab power in these co-operatives and extend its political sway.